Follow Me
  Janine Campbell
  • Home
  • Blended Learning
  • Assessment
  • Thematic Units
  • Publications
  • Lights, Camera, Learning
  • Get Your Grant On

breaking assessment

7/14/2012

4 Comments

 
Picture
Color Wheel Mandala by Reed J.
 One of the hardest things about my job is assessing student work. Everything else I consider to be fun - I love teaching my students new art skills, materials, artists, and connections between art and other subjects/life.  Nothing beats the moment a student says "This is the best thing I have ever made," or when they receive recognition at a local or national competition - it is seriously why I come back every year to try and outdo the previous, and it is why grading student work can be such a difficult task.

For the past couple of years I have done something different with assessment in my classroom. Instead of giving students a rubric before I get started on a project, I ask them what they think they should be graded and we create the rubric together. I was nervous the first couple of times I did this, and there was even resistance from students (I had one tell me in a exit interview that they like it better if I just tell them so they didn't have to think about it), but I really cannot see myself going back.

One reason is that this allows for both formative and summative assessment to take place. The formative component occurs when students are describing the qualities they think they should be graded on in their work. It allows for me to see if the main concepts from the lesson were learned by students. If we are studying abstract art and students are about to make an abstraction of something, but then tell me they think they should be graded on their ability to draw in a realistic manner it lets me know that I did not get across the meaning of abstraction and need to reteach the concept. The summative assessment comes from the project itself and whether or not they were able to follow to the rubric that we created as a class.

Another reason I will continue to use this method in my class is because it gives students the opportunity to have a say in how they are being graded. Anytime students are given an opportunity to have a hand in their own learning is a good thing. It is always interesting to see what students say they should be graded on when we do this, and although you might think each class would come up with completely different things, they don't.

Instead, students from different classes use similar language. Two criteria (also known as focus correction areas adapted from Collins Writing) seem to be consistent - RBE (reasonable best effort) and Craftsmanship. The other criteria are more specific to the project at hand. For example, if we are doing color wheel mandalas, students usually say that the other criteria should be creativity, the symmetry of the design, and the use of color. I try to keep the criteria to four or five things that can be specifically measured when we create the rubrics as a class. When we write down their criteria, we then go into what each should look like in their work. This helps students focus on the main ideas of what they need to execute and it also helps me focus on what to assess. It takes the guessing and ambiguity out of grading for both of us and makes it a little more pleasant.

Do you have a trick to assessment that seems to be working for you? Please share your thoughts below and let me know what you think of this idea and if you have done something similar in your own classroom.
4 Comments
LockIe Chapman
7/14/2012 07:51:27 am

I love this Janine-- I think students really benefit when we give them opportunities to synthesize their thinking . I ask my 8th grade students to look at state standards in Vis arts and to reflect and write about they met any or all standards. I learn do much from what they say and I know the process helps them as well!

Reply
Janine Campbell
7/14/2012 08:46:15 am

Thanks Lockle - It is always best when learning is more than a one way street. If we are being effective teachers, then asking students what they should be assessed on can reflect that. Thanks for the encouragement and sharing your experience.

Reply
Pete Jones link
7/14/2012 08:49:30 am

I do pretty much the same as you but hoping to introduce solo taxonomy next year which I feel is the missing link!

Reply
Janine Campbell
7/14/2012 09:43:04 am

Awesome - how do you think you might do that?

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Janine Campbell

    Visual Arts Teacher at Byron Center West Middle School. Check out their classroom blog.

    Archives

    August 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    December 2015
    October 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    August 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012

    Categories

    All
    Assessment
    Awards
    Blog
    Chicago
    Choice
    Classroom
    Conference
    Connections
    Display
    Drawing
    Ecet2
    Education
    Exhibit
    Flint Institute Of Arts
    Fraggle Rock
    Grades
    Home
    Inspiration
    Keynote
    Labels
    Learning
    Macul
    #macul16
    MAEA
    Materials
    Moodle
    Movies
    NAEA
    #NAEA15
    #NAEA16
    Paris
    PBS LearningMedia
    Reflection
    Sub Plans
    Teaching
    Technology
    Travel
    Turtleman
    Twitter
    WGVU

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.